Auto Body Services

Deer Hit Specialists

From minor dents to panel replacement, we restore your vehicle to pre-accident condition.

Collision Repair

Wisconsin roads are tough — we fix front-end impacts, broken lights, and body panel damage.

Insurance Claim Assistance

We work directly with your provider to simplify the process.

Paint Matching & Refinishing

Seamless color blending with factory-grade finishes.

OEM Parts

Your car was made with OEM parts, and that’s what we believe it should be repaired with.

Our Mission

At Tolly Collision, we treat every customer like family — because we know how much your vehicle means to yours. Our mission is to provide honest, high-quality collision and deer damage repair that keeps your family safe and your car looking its best. Whether it’s your daily driver, your teen’s first car, or the family SUV, we take pride in restoring it with care, precision, and integrity.

We’re here to make a stressful situation easier — with friendly service, clear communication, and repairs you can trust.

Learn more
A close-up of a dart hitting the bullseye on a dartboard.

Become a part of our community

Find us on Facebook

Red work van with the hood open, showing the engine, parked on a gravel lot with a building and trees in the background.
Red work van parked in front of a garage with signs, with trees in the background.
A green car with a damaged front end, showing the open hood and visible engine components, with a piece of the front bumper and headlight assembly damaged.
Green Subaru Outback parked on a gravel driveway in front of a wooden garage and rural buildings with trees in the background.